More than 80 years after George Orwell wrote in his classic Animal Farm that "all animals are equal, but some are more equal than others," his barbed observation on disparity rings ever truer for humankind.
According to a 2017 report by the international charity, Oxfam, eight of the world's billionaires hold as much wealth as half of the rest of the global population, which is some 3.5 billion people—many of whom are living in grinding poverty.
Despite improvements in some parts of the globe, the World Bank says "extreme poverty remains unacceptably high."1 Globally, 1 in 10 is below the poverty line, somehow surviving on less than $1.90 a day.
If such staggering inequality—"beyond grotesque," said Oxfam chief executive Mark Goldring—doesn't provoke the rich to concern for reasons of the heart, it should at least cause them to reflect on the ongoing health of their wallets. The World Economic Forum sees the rising gap between the haves and the have-nots, and the social polarization it breeds, as a major threat to world financial stability.2
Such kinds of situations, the more extreme of a continuum of injustices, continue across Asia and other parts of the world because of a complex web of factors: social prejudice, gender discrimination, lack of education, and more.
Not surprisingly, then, fair employment and rights at work are among the core emphases of the United Nations' annual World Day of Social Justice, to be celebrated on Feb. 20.
Poverty is not just a divide between the West and the rest, however. The gap between the rich and the poor may be as wide as an ocean or as narrow as a billboard.
Globally, one in 10 is below the poverty line, somehow surviving on less than $1.90 a day
With booming technology and industry sectors, India's economy is presently the sixth largest in the world and has created more than one hundred billionaires. Its financial strength is much of the reason for the World Bank tracking South Asia as the world's fastest-growing region.3
Yet, "The effects of an increasingly sophisticated and prosperous India have not reached its poorest and least educated citizens," concludes Devin Finn in an article for the University of Denver's Human Rights and Contemporary Slavery digest on bonded labor.
Across South Asia, "Hundreds of millions more live slightly above the poverty line, more than 200 million live in slums, and about 500 million go without electricity," notes the World Bank. Though the number of people in the region living in "extreme poverty" has been slashed in the past decade, around 62 million children still must work to help support their families.
Worldwide, there are around 168 million of such child laborers, according to the International Labor Organization (ILO), half of them engaged in hazardous work "which endangers their health, safety and moral development."4
Many of the world's poor are not just struggling to survive, they have even lost their freedom. The ILO estimates that more than 40 million people around the world are currently living in some form of slavery. Of that number, some 25 million are to be found in Asia and the Pacific, where the region also accounts for 73 percent of all victims of forced sexual exploitation.
Some of those in forced labor are to be found working in brick kilns, with entire families—and, in some cases, even whole villages—laboring to pay off what started as a small loan and became, through withholding of wages and other abuses, an ever-increasing debt. Children and adults alike work long hours in difficult conditions.
After the International Justice Mission worked with local authorities to free 260 people caught in forced labor at one brick factory, a father told how he and his family were tricked into working there.6
Promises of a good salary did not materialize, he recalled. Instead, they were forced to work 16 hours a day, seven days a week. Despite sustaining minor injuries while mixing and making bricks, they were never allowed to go to the hospital. The children were beaten with a pipe and verbally abused if they were caught playing when they were supposed to be working.
Similar exploitation occurs in the tea and handmade carpet industries. One investigation of a large plantation found "a shocking disregard for health and safety,"7 with workers spraying chemicals without protection, children working, and families forced to defecate among the tea bushes because there were no toilets.
The International Labor Organization completed a recent study8 of conditions in the Uzbekistan cotton harvest, historically labeled as one of the worst human rights violations of forced labor. While it was stated by The Cotton Campaign9 in 2015 and 2016 that "the government of Uzbekistan forced more than a million people, including students, teachers, doctors, nurses, and employees of government agencies and private businesses to the cotton fields, against their will and under threat of penalty, especially losing their jobs," the ILO study noted distinct improvements in 2017. It concluded that "the systematic use of child labor in Uzbekistan's cotton harvest has come to an end" and that efforts were being made to ensure all labor was voluntary. Still, the ILO found that "a certain number pick cotton during at least some part of the harvest as a result of persuasion, pressure or coercion." Uzbekistan president Savkat Mirziyoyev stated at the United Nations General Assembly that "In cooperation with the International Labor Organization, we have taken effective measures to eradicate the child and forced labor."
Anti-Slavery International (ASI) identifies the main barriers to the eradication of slavery as "strict hierarchical social structures and caste systems; poverty; discrimination against women and girls; and lack of respect for children's rights and development needs."10
Many millions more may not be so clearly enslaved, but they are also caught in poverty's endless cycle, scrabbling to make a living as day laborers or scavengers. Often, parents are forced to make their children work too, to try to make ends meet. But keeping them out of school just ensures another generation remains on the bottom rung of the ladder.
The number of out-of-school children in South Asia constitutes "a formidable challenge," says the ILO. It estimates more than 25 million boys and girls aged 7 to 14 do not attend school in Pakistan, Bangladesh and India alone.
Lack of opportunities for fair and meaningful work is not just about financial well-being, of course.
"Far from economic inequality being seen as purely a 'labor rights' issue, the world is realizing that economic and social inequalities are intrinsically linked to human rights," says U.K.-based ASI. "Inequality is one of the biggest human rights issues of our time."
Very practically, poor working conditions and poor pay mean poor health. According to the World Health Organization (WHO), "Nearly 9 million children under the age of five die every year, according to 2007 figures." And of those children, one-in-three deaths are linked to malnutrition.11 And in some impoverished communities in Asia, more than half of the children have a body mass index below 18.5, writes Satya Sagar for the Canada-based Centre for Research in Globalization (CRG)12, "which is regarded as chronic sub-nutrition-placing them by World Health Organization standards in a permanent state of famine."
Injustice in Social Structures
For those who are considered "Untouchables"—that's some 300 million Dalits who fall at the bottom of the societal ladder—discrimination typically leaves them with only menial work no one else wants to do.
The Indian government took affirmative action to enforce policies about caste discrimination "reserving a certain percentage of government jobs and admission to educational institutions, as also financial support through loans and special schemes, for these castes," reports the CRG.
Some Dalits have managed to break out of their long-time social, religious and economic confinement. Recently launched, The Dalit Enterprise celebrates the rise of entrepreneurs from among the Dalits, among whom are around 50 billionaires.
But such successes are often the exception rather than the rule. Seven decades after the government first introduced measures to address the caste issue, the CRG's Sagar notes "there is not a single positive indicator of social development" where lower castes feature prominently.
"Whether it is land holdings, income, literacy, nutrition or health status, it is these sections-who constitute one-third of India's population-that are right at the bottom of the pile," he says.
Migrant workers endure discrimination and social injustices too. In the 2018 Human Rights Watch Report on Sri Lanka, WHO reports that "The government took some steps to protect the rights of more than 1 million migrant workers in the Middle East and other parts of Asia, but many continued to face long working hours with little rest, delayed or unpaid wages, confinement in the workplace, and verbal, physical, and sexual abuse."
"There's so much improvement and progress in this world," she said. "But for us, nothing has changed. We're still in the same hell."
Cultural attitudes often limit women's opportunities to work; they are expected to stay home and look after their families. Female participation rates in the workforce are low in the entire region, while only one in three women in Bangladesh participates, says the World Bank.13
Women working in brick kilns as part of a bonded labor family are what ASI calls "invisible"—not even formally registered on the employment roll, with wages paid only to their husbands.
Often forced to work in what are called "vulnerable" occupations, informal employment where they have no rights, women are more susceptible to financial exploitation.
Pushed to the fringes, women may be forced to do jobs others refuse, like Suneeta. She told Germany's Deutsche Welle how she had been a manual scavenger—cleaning latrines by hand for 20 years to feed her family.
"There's so much improvement and progress in this world," she said. "But for us, nothing has changed. We're still in the same hell."14
Widows are particularly vulnerable, often shunned because they are considered cursed and left to beg or even forced into prostitution.
Frequently involved in "cultural employment"—handcrafts and similar arts-based fields—women are more likely to have to supplement their income with more than one job, says the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) report Precarious situation for women working in the field of culture.
Females at risk
Illiteracy is a dangerous factor. The more than 250 million women across Asia who are unable to read are vulnerable to exploitation—unable to understand an employment contract (if they are given one) or the details of a loan they may need to take out—and at risk of being cheated when they spend their money.
There are health consequences, too. In a University of California, Berkeley paper, The Rural-Urban Divide in India, Tathagato Chakraborty writes that lack of educational opportunities for girls "increases the fertility rate, maternal and infant mortality, and malnutrition in the family." With little education, basic hygiene practices may remain unknown. Furthermore, because the rights of women to land and property are rarely recognized, "this increases the risk of poverty to women and their families and increases poverty overall as women and children make up two-thirds of the population."
Then there is violence and abuse, physical and sexual. Many young girls are kept away from school not only because they are required to work, but also for fear they may be attacked on the way to school or while they are there, according to the United Nations Economic and Social Commission for Asia and the Pacific (UNESCAP).
Indeed, the World Health Organization names gender-based violence as "a significant public health concern in the South-East Asia Region," and "one of the most pervasive human rights violations."15
Girls are "particularly vulnerable to the negative impacts of child labor," says the ILO, comprising the bulk of children in "some of the most dangerous forms of child labor, including forced and bonded labor, commercial sexual exploitation and domestic work outside of their home."
Part of the problem is that attitudes are slow to change, as noted last year by Dr. Poonam Khetrapal Singh, WHO regional director for South-East Asia, when he introduced the International Day for the Elimination of Violence against Women.
"Gender inequality is at the root of violence against women," he said. "Beliefs and practices that value women less than men are normalized, excused and tolerated—a substantial proportion of adolescent girls and boys believe that a husband is justified in beating his wife for at least one reason."16
Realizing that millions of women in India have become exposed to sexual assaults each year simply because of the lack of toilets, the government of India has taken up the task of building toilets and latrines in the rural parts of the nation. The construction of toilets under Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s dream project, Swachh Bharat Abhiyan (Clean India Mission), has gained momentum, with many NGO’s (like Sulabh International) joining the initiative. Gospel for Asia helped to build and install over 10,000 toilets in 2016.
Small Steps, Big Change
In the face of such enormous inequalities, it can be difficult to know how to respond and where to start. But just as the problem of social injustice is not really a single, abstract issue so much as the many individuals it affects, so ending inequality is about changing personal circumstances as well as addressing the structures that allow inequality to continue.
That sort of action is taking place on large and small scales. At one end of the spectrum, the World Bank is supporting a $63 million empowerment project in Jharkhand, India, which aims to help adolescent girls and young women complete secondary-level education and acquire job skills.
Another way of improving the situation for poor families has been providing microloans that keep them away from predatory loan sharks. Many families have found themselves caught in bonded labor for generations after borrowing a small sum, only for their debt to keep spiraling beyond their reach.
The "Jeevika" program launched a decade ago in Bihar, India by the state and national Indian government has seen some 600,000 women helped to start small businesses as farmers, dairy and poultry producers and entrepreneurs in small businesses.
"These women are also emerging as a political and social force," notes India Spend.
The 2016 Global Gender Gap Report by the World Economic Forum concludes that at its current rate of progress, it will take South Asia an entire millennium to reach gender equality in the workplace.
Increasingly aware of living in a globalized economy, where production is outsourced to where labor may be cheapest, some in the West are recognizing how their spending may affect the poor in other parts of the world.
Ending inequality is about changing personal circumstances as well as addressing the structures that allow inequality to continue
Yet while encouraging Western consumers to challenge companies about their supply chain practices, to ensure they are not supporting sweatshop businesses, groups like ASI don't advocate boycotts.
Such actions "can actually make the situation worse and undermine the economy of an already poor country," says the organization. "As well as hurting employers using slavery-like practices, they could also hurt those who are not exploiting their workers, and worsen the poverty that is one of the root causes of slavery."
Gospel for Asia Fights for the Social Justice on a Local Level
Complex though the issues are, simple actions can make a difference. Through a wide range of services and programs, Gospel for Asia (GFA) is working among Asia's poor to offer help and hope for a better tomorrow. And GFA can testify that even a small gift for a family can create big change.17
Vocational training courses that cost just $30 can teach skills like fishing, welding and tailoring to equip men for better-paying work. For $75, GFA provides tool kits that may include items like axes, shovels, saws and plows, which enable farmers to increase their productivity.
An $85 donation supplies a sewing machine that allows men and women to start a home-based business, rather than being dependent on others. Not only does this mean they can work from home and take better care of their children, it also multiplies their income significantly. Many who have received a machine say they no longer feel they need to keep their children from school to help make money.
Costing $200, a rickshaw opens up a whole new level of opportunity for a family. Instead of having to rent a vehicle at often high rates, rickshaw drivers can keep all their earnings from ferrying passengers and products around.
Gospel for Asia also helps to ensure that a family's situation improves beyond one generation, by encouraging parents to keep their children free from the burden of work. Indeed, GFA sees education as important as equipment, if not more so, in bringing about long-term change.
Currently, around 75,000 children are enrolled in GFA-supported Bridge of Hope centers, where they are helped with their schooling and holistic development. Since 2004, many others have come through this program, which also provides food and medical checkups.
The importance of greater access to education, especially for women and girls, cannot be emphasized enough. Funding such efforts "isn't charity but investment, and the returns are transformational," notes activist and singer Bono in a recent opinion piece for Time magazine in which he asserts that "poverty is sexist."
When girls get an extra year's schooling, their wages increase by almost 12 percent, he writes. Closing the gender gap in education could generate up to $152 billion a year for developing countries.
"When you invest in girls and women," he goes on, "they rise and they lift their families, their communities, their economies and countries along with them."
One example of that is recounted in Global Fund for Women's (GFW) Breaking Through report on gender equality in Asia and the Pacific. After joining a women's self-help group, a 29-year-old became the first housewife elected to the panchayat, or local government, also helping win equal pay for equal work for women at a local factory.
New opportunities have opened up for the more than 100,000 women who have completed one of GFA's literacy courses. Another 30,000 women are currently taking part in the program, which is offered in 16 languages.
One graduate of the GFA-supported literacy program told how learning to read at the age of 40 had changed her life.
"I have been deceived many times because of my illiteracy," says Baasima.18 "When I used to go for shopping, bad shopkeepers deceived me, taking more money and not returning the balance amount. But now I can calculate myself. They cannot deceive me. I am very happy now."
Learning to read has not only enabled Baasima and others to provide and care for their families better-the health of your child is endangered when you can't read a prescription they may need-but it has also raised their standing in their communities. And along with that improved status can come a new sense of personal worth and identity as they discover God's love for them in the pages of the Bible.
Indeed, all of GFA's efforts to address the inequalities that press down on millions across Asia are anchored in the belief that true social justice means not only seeking better opportunities for all economically and educationally, but also spiritually-the chance to hear of a God who loves all equally, and to see that love demonstrated through actions that help lift them up.
While GFA celebrates the attention that the annual World Day of Social Justice brings to the plight of the overlooked and down-trodden and the enormity of the challenge, it quietly works year-round to change things one person at a time, echoing the approach of Mother Teresa, who remarked of her years caring for some of India's poor that, "There are no great acts, only small acts done with great love."
GFA workers seek to walk out the call of the prophet Isaiah (1:17):
Learn to do right; seek justice.
Defend the oppressed.
Take up the cause of the fatherless;
plead the case of the widow."
Give to Provide Vocational Training
A donation to GFA's Vocational Training fund can help a mother or father in Asia learn a valuable skill, generating income to escape the cycle of poverty.